Matthew Donkin is a much sought-after barrister, trusted to conduct cases of gravity and complexity and recognised for his expertise in handling demanding and technical evidence and legal issues.

Crime

Having developed a strong reputation for defending and prosecuting cases of general crime, Matthew is now frequently instructed in cases of homicide and organised crime including drug, firearm and fraud offences.  He also accepts instructions in cases involving allegations of sexual offending with particular complicating or unique features.  He has a long history of acting as junior alone, being led by Queen’s Counsel and also as leading junior.

At only ten years call, Matthew was appointed to the CPS panel of prosecutors at level 4 and has also been appointed at level 4 to the Rape and Serious Sexual Offences panel.  Matthew’s expertise in handling some of the most demanding cases before the Crown Court has also seen him recently appointed to the Specialist Panel for Serious Crime, so marking him as one of a select group of junior advocates to be considered for instruction in the most serious cases in which a junior would be instructed.

Inquests and Inquiries

Matthew accepts instructions to appear in Inquests and has done so in cases concerning fatal traffic accidents and police misconduct.

Regulatory

Matthew accepts instructions to represent diverse parties in a broad range of regulatory proceedings.

 

Notable Cases

  • R v Craig Keeler - Causing death by dangerous driving

    Causing Death by Dangerous Driving. Durham Crown Court.  H. H. Judge Carroll.

    Junior alone. Instructed by Michael Henderson & Co. Solicitors.

    In an episode of deliberately intimidatory driving the defendant pursued the deceased for a distance of over 6 miles in County Durham in circumstances not explained to the Court. The deceased was driving a car in an unsafe state and had been out into the early hours and had taken cocaine.  He was in the process of making a 999 call to the police to report that he was being chased when the fatal collision took place.

  • R v AC – Manslaughter

    Junior to Robert Smith Q.C.  Newcastle Crown Court.  2018.  Prosecution of a father for the manslaughter of his fifteen-week old son.  Issues of neuropathology, paediatric cardiology, ophthalmic pathology and other complex medical evidence to prove that the causation of the sudden deterioration and subsequent death of the child was due to traumatic head injury arising from an episode of shaking.

  • R v Adam Parkin - Murder

    Murder and attempted murder. Newcastle Crown Court.  The Honorary Recorder of Newcastle.

    Led by Robert Smith Q.C. Instructed by CPS Special Crime and Counter-Terrorism Division.

    The defendant was accused of the murder of his wife and the attempted murder of his two step-children. Issues of the defendant’s psychiatric state of mind and background.

    The defendant had been employed in a management role at CPS Northumbria with regional and national responsibilities. Immediately after the charge of the defendant, Matthew was instructed to conduct the prosecution of this sensitive case.

  • R v Brendan Teague - Attempted Murder

    Attempted murder. Newcastle Crown Court.  H. H. Judge Moreland.

    Junior alone. Instructed by CPS Northumbria.

    The defendant carried out a pre-arranged plan to attend at his victim’s home under the pretence of supplying him with cannabis, and when his attention was diverted, he stabbed him three times with a kitchen knife before fleeing the scene. The victim survived only by virtue of the prompt arrival of the emergency services.

  • R v Daniel Johnson - Murder

    Murder. Newcastle Crown Court.  Mr. Justice Males.

    Led by Robert Smith Q.C. Instructed by CPS Northumbria.

    The defendant came across a male late at night, robbed him and took his house keys. He then used those keys to access the male’s flat where he found his victim asleep in bed and brutally murdered him.  The defendant then left the scene and remained at large for fifteen months.  The case involved issues of digital image and facial morphology comparison, gait and height comparison, DNA analysis and voice and accent recognition evidence.

  • R v Liam Morris - Manslaughter

    Manslaughter. Sheffield Crown Court.  Mr. Justice Goss.

    Junior alone. Instructed by Law24 solicitors, Sheffield.

    Defence of a young man accused of a ‘one-strike manslaughter’ who had been in Sheffield city centre with friends when approached by the deceased who wished to sell a watch, which he had recently stolen from a shop, for the purpose of receiving cash to buy some heroin. In a short scuffle the defendant swung his arm once, causing a blow to the deceased that knocked him to the ground.  The deceased’s head struck the ground causing a fracture to the skull and fatal subdural haemorrhage.  Issues of self-defence and causation of death.

  • R v Duggan, Lamont & Others - Murder

    Murder. Newcastle Crown Court.  Mr. Justice Globe.

    Led by Robert Smith Q.C. Instructed by CPS Northumbria.

    Prosecution of four defendants for the horrific killing of a man using knives and a pipe-cutter of a man in an alley in Sunderland. The deceased had attended following a report of an attack on his own son, and when he arrived the perpetrators emerged from a rear yard armed with weapons.  Issues of causation, infliction of injury and joint enterprise – primary and secondary offenders.

  • R v VB & CN - Causing the death of a child

    Causing/Allowing the Death of a Child. Newcastle Crown Court.  Mr. Justice Jay.

    Led by Robert Smith Q.C. Instructed by CPS Northumbria.

    A baby girl was found limp and not-breathing and died shortly thereafter. Her mother and partner had been involved in an alcohol and drug-fuelled row in the early hours of the morning, although neither would account for the collapse of the child or her injuries.  Issues of causation of sudden collapse and death and the identification of how she had come about her injuries.

  • R v Michael Parkin - Attempted Murder and Arson

    Attempted Murder. Sheffield Crown Court.  The Honorary Recorder of Sheffield.

    Junior alone. Instructed by CPS Yorkshire and Humberside.

    Against a background of domestic violence and control, the defendant beat his partner and doused her in petrol and attempted to spark a lighter to set fire to her and then to the home, causing the victim to flee leaving her infant son inside the house.

  • R v O'Brien, Walters, Walters and Poppe - Murder and Perverting the Course of Justice

    Murder, manslaughter and perverting the course of justice. Sheffield Crown Court.  The Honorary Recorder of Sheffield.

    Led by Robert Smith Q.C. Instructed by CPS Yorkshire and Humberside.

    The victim was stabbed death over a drugs debt that the defendants had taken on as they attempted to exert their control over the Darnall area. There was no direct evidence of who was responsible for the murder.  Issues of DNA comparison, telephone attribution and cell-site and voice recognition.  A particular issue is that of the two male voices heard at the time of the stabbing one of them shouted “stop”.  This defendant was convicted of manslaughter.

  • R v Wilson - Attempted Murder

    Attempted murder. Nottingham Crown Court.  The Honorary Recorder of Nottingham.

    Junior alone. Instructed by Elliot Mather Solicitors, Chesterfield.

    The defendant had deliberately driven his car at his own father, then repeatedly driven backwards and forwards over him when on the ground. Convicted of causing grievous bodily harm with intent contrary to section 18.  The issues surrounded the defendant’s state of mind and intention.

  • R v Mark Ross - GBH with intent

    Causing grievous bodily harm with intent. York Crown Court.  The Honorary Recorder of York.

    Junior alone. Instructed by CPS North Yorkshire.

    The defendant returned to a pub from which he had earlier been ejected and assaulted an elderly man by knocking him to the ground and repeatedly driving his skull against a kerb, leaving him with catastrophic and life-changing injuries. Issues of self-defence and how many times the victim’s head was struck against the ground, proven by expert medical evidence identifying the pattern of fractures to the skull to demonstrate separate impacts.

  • R v Andrew Knapper - Murder

    Murder. Nottingham Crown Court.  H. H. Judge Teare.

    Led by Shaun Smith Q.C. Instructed by Elliot Mather Solicitors.

    The defendant learned of an affair between his wife and best-friend and immediately drove to his home address and stabbed his wife repeatedly in the presence of their two sons. Issues of loss of control and mental health.

Notable Cases

  • R v Conroy, Appleby and others – Operation Eton 2

    Conspiracy to possess a firearm with intent to endanger life. Newcastle Crown Court 2019.  H. H. Judge Batiste.

    Leading junior, leading Richard Holland. Instructed by Complex Case Unit, CPS Northumbria.

    Prosecution of six members of an organised crime group who – in furtherance of a feud with a rival group in the West end of Newcastle, carried out shootings targeting the homes of their rivals. This successful prosecution required the careful and structured presentation of a number of different areas of evidence including DNA and fingerprint comparison, mobile telephone attribution, call data and RF survey cell-site evidence, comparison of firearms and ammunition and the enhanced interpretation of recordings from CCTV cameras.

  • R v AB - Operations Haymarket and Sidra 2.

    Conspiracy to possess a firearm and conspiracy to supply cocaine. Newcastle Crown Court and Teesside Crown Court.  H. H. Judge Moreland and H. H. Judge Sherwin.

    Junior alone. Instructed by Michael Henderson & Co. Solicitors.

    Matthew represented a client who was prosecuted in two separate trials for his alleged role in organised crime in Sunderland.

    The first trial alleged a conspiracy to possess a firearm associated with drug-related offending. The issues in the case concerned the extensive covert surveillance operation conducted by police, PII and the extent of the involvement of a registered informant and mobile telephone evidence.

    The second trial was an allegation of involvement in a widespread conspiracy to supply cocaine over a period of over 12 months. The evidence in this case principally concentrated on the role of a registered informant and assisting offender – ‘CW’ – and the account that he gave about multiple persons, along with telephone evidence said to support those allegations.

  • R v Roman Rafael and others – Operations Cluster and Trojan

    Modern Slavery. Teesside Crown Court.  H. H. Judge Armstrong.

    Led by John Elvidge Q.C. Instructed by Complex Case Unit, CPS Northumbria.

    Prosecution of nine members of a Slovakian organised crime family group based in Newcastle who had, for a number of years, trafficked targeted vulnerable EU citizens into the UK. Once in the UK the slaves were kept ignorant of their status and sufficiently housed and fed so that they would not complain.  The defendants controlled all of their money, took out loans and made benefits claims in their names.

    This was an enormous case, one of the most complex and high-profile cases brought under the Modern Slavery Act in the country, and which also involved the instruction of a second junior advocate, Richard Holland. The trial lasted for fifteen weeks.

    The case attracted national media attention.

  • R v Zaman and others – Operation Emerald

    Conspiracy to supply Heroin and Cocaine. Newcastle Crown Court.  H. H. Judge Moreland.

    Leading junior, leading Graham O’Sullivan. Instructed by Complex Case Unit, CPS Northumbria.

    Prosecution of members of an organised crime group who were importing bulk quantities of heroin and crack cocaine into the North East for distribution in Newcastle and Cleveland where it was disbursed to ‘street level’ dealers. The case relied upon the presentation of months of surveillance and mobile telephone evidence.

    This case also involved the use of a police intelligence source known as ‘XY’, a convicted rapist who had assisted the broad police investigation as an informant. In October 2016 the defendants sought to have the proceedings stayed on the grounds of an abuse of process, along with other defendants in a case known as Operation Shelter.  In the abuse of process proceedings Matthew acted as a further junior to John Elvidge Q.C.

    The case attracted national media attention.

  • R v Hassan, Foster and Ismail

    Kidnap, False Imprisonment and Possession of Firearms.   Sheffield Crown Court.  H. H. Judge Moore.

    Junior alone. Instructed by Complex Case Unit, CPS Yorkshire and Humber.

    Prosecution of three defendants who had arranged a meeting for an apparent drug deal, but then produced a firearm and kidnapped the two complainants. Ransom demands were made and the police conducted an urgent live operation of negotiating with the defendants whilst identifying where they were holding the victims captive.  The incident resolved when armed police officers intercepted the defendants who were driving to the arranged location for transfer of money and captives.  Issues of identification, DNA evidence and voice recognition.

Notable Cases

  • R v WO

    Rape. Assault by penetration and sexual activity with child family member.  Newcastle Crown Court.

    Junior alone. Instructed by RASSO unit, CPS Northumbria.

    Non-historical case of a father of previous good character who for a number of years had committed serious sexual offences against his daughters.

  • R v NS

    Sexual Activity with a child family member. Newcastle Crown Court.  H. H. Judge Sherwin.

    Junior alone.  Instructed by RASSO unit, CPS Northumbria.

    Father who had sexually assaulted his daughter. The sole evidence was from his daughter who gave her account aged 3 and was aged 4 by the time of the trial.

  • R v Mohammed Ghani

    Indecent assault and sexual activity with a child. Leeds Crown Court.  Mr. Recorder Wynn.

    Junior alone. Instructed by RASSO unit, CPS Yorkshire and Humber.

    Prosecution of a local Imam who was well-known and highly respected in West Yorkshire for many years of sexual abuse of a girl at times when he was teaching her Urdu and studying the Koran.

  • R v DW

    Rape and Sexual Assault on a Child.  Newcastle Crown Court. H. H. Judge Mallett.

    Junior alone. Instructed by RASSO unit, CPS Northumbria.

    The defendant raped and sexually assaulted his 10-year-old daughter on days when she would stay at his home as part of ongoing contact arrangements. The principle evidence arose from the child who was aged 11 at trial.

  • R v TB

    Rape. Sheffield Crown Court.  H. H. Judge Kelson Q.C.

    Junior alone.  Instructed by Khan Solicitors.

    Representing defendant in multi-handed case in which multiple complainants living in the care system in South Yorkshire alleged grooming and sexual abuse by large numbers of men.

  • R v CU

    Derby Crown Court.  H. H. Judge Gosling.

    Junior alone.  Instructed by Elliot Mather Solicitors.

    The defendant, a man with significantly reduced functioning following a road traffic accident and brain injury when aged 12, was known to the complainant and she accused him of entering her home when she slept and sexually assaulted her. The defence case was that this was a fabrication for the purpose of obtaining money from him, knowing that he had received a substantial compensation payment.  The defendant had the benefit of an intermediary at trial.  The successful defence included raising issues of disclosure, of motive and bad character of the complainant and the unique feature of being resolved at a re-trial in which a juror from the original trial was called to give evidence by the Judge hearing the case.

Notable Cases

  • R v CK and others

    Section 19 Costs Application. Newcastle Crown Court.  H. H. Judge Spragg.

    Led by Robert Smith Q.C. Instructed by Specialist Fraud Division of the CPS.

    Following an unsuccessful prosecution of defendants for a large-scale insurance fraud, Matthew and Robert Smith Q.C. were instructed to represent the Crown Prosecution Service following significant applications for costs made on behalf of the defendants. Issues of the appropriateness of charge and continued prosecution, disclosure exercise, the conduct and responsibilities of legal representatives.

  • R v Roman Rafael and others

    Confiscation proceedings. Teesside Crown Court.  H. H. Judge Armstrong.

    Junior alone. Instructed by CPS Northumbria.

    Matthew is conducting the confiscation proceedings arising from this Modern Slavery Case, with a combined total value of over £1 million.

  • R v Devalapally and others

    Fraud and Money-Laundering. Leeds Crown Court.  H. H. Judge Mairs.

    Junior alone. Instructed by CPS Yorkshire and Humberside.

    The defendants were part of a nationwide network of criminals responsible for fraud and money-laundering of hundreds of thousands of pounds, money was then swiftly dissipated across dozens of bank accounts held in multiple names before being realised as cash or transferred out of the country.

  • R v Ali, Zaman and others

    Conspiracy to handle stolen goods and Trademarks Act offences. Bradford Crown Court.  The Honorary Recorder of Bradford.

    Leading junior, leading James Gelsthorpe. Instructed by Complex Case Unit, CPS Yorkshire and Humber.

    Prosecution of seven defendants for conspiracy to handle stolen goods and selling counterfeit goods, including the two architects of this high value conspiracy. The defendants were close to criminal gangs responsible for thefts of bulk quantities of electrical goods which were then sold through an ever-changing network of eBay, PayPal and other accounts.  Issues in the case included the identification of controlling email accounts and IP addresses to link the selling and money-receiving online accounts, and linking those to multiple bank accounts from which money was withdrawn.

    In 2017 Matthew conducted the high-value Proceeds of Crime Act proceedings, in which the Benefit Figure was in excess of £1 million.

  • R v Moate, MacInnes and others

    Conspiracy to Steal. Leeds Crown Court.  Mr. Recorder Wright Q.C.

    Junior alone. Instructed by CPS Yorkshire and Humber.

    Prosecution of an organised gang responsible for the targeted theft of thirty-two high value cars which were stolen by a ruse with a fake interested buyer and within an extremely short time taken to a safe location, stripped down and parts replaced, before transport to other parts of the country.

Notable Cases

  • Inquest into the death of Irene Collins

    Matthew represented the family of the deceased who had allowed the police access to her property to carry out a search with a dog, but the police dog then attacked and savaged the deceased. The case attracted national media attention.

Notable Cases

"He is very well respected and very hard-working." "He is extremely capable, thorough and a very good team player."
Chambers & Partners 2020 (Crime)

Practice Areas

Appointments & Memberships

  • CPS Level 4 Prosecutor
  • CPS Panel for Rape and Serious Sexual Offences at Level 4
  • Appointed to CPS Specialist Panel for Serious Crime at Level 4
  • Approved Advocacy Trainer
  • Criminal Bar Association
  • North Eastern Circuit

Education

  • BVC, University of Northumbria (2004)
  • LLB (Hons), University of Leicester (2002)

Privacy Notice

Shortlist Builder

Close

Select the Practice Areas that you would like to download or add to the shortlist

Download Add to shortlist
Portfolio close
Title Type CV Email

Remove All

Download


Click here to email this list.